Review: Comes a Time by Neil Young (2017 Reissue, Vinyl Record)

Review: Comes a Time by Neil Young (2017 Reissue, Vinyl Record)

Neil Young’s Comes a Time, originally released in 1978, finds renewed life in its 2017 vinyl reissue—an album that remains a cornerstone of his acoustic, country-folk period. While Neil is best known for his raw electric work with Crazy Horse, Comes a Time is a reminder of his gentler, introspective side.

Warm, Rooted, and Timeless

The album is centered around themes of aging, love, and reflection. The reissue brings out the warmth of Young’s acoustic arrangements, giving songs like “Goin’ Back” and “Already One” a lush, analog glow. The vinyl pressing is clean and dynamic, offering a rich listening experience that complements the record’s earthy instrumentation.

Key Highlights

“Comes a Time” – A gentle opener with harmonies from Nicolette Larson, setting the tone for the entire album’s peaceful mood.
“Look Out for My Love” – One of the few tracks featuring Crazy Horse, it bridges Neil’s acoustic leanings with a gritty edge.
“Lotta Love” – Later made famous by Larson herself, this version is heartfelt and direct.
“Four Strong Winds” – A stunning cover of Ian Tyson’s folk classic, Neil’s delivery feels weathered and sincere.

The 2017 Vinyl Edition

This reissue retains the original album's charm while improving sound quality. The remaster respects the analog warmth and keeps the subtle textures intact. Fans of vinyl will appreciate the packaging—simple but classic, in line with Neil’s no-frills aesthetic.

Final Thoughts

Comes a Time isn’t the loudest or most experimental Neil Young album, but it’s among the most heartfelt. The 2017 vinyl reissue does justice to the original, giving listeners a beautifully preserved window into a quieter chapter of Young’s career.

Rating: ★★★★☆ (4.5/5) – A must-have for fans of Neil’s acoustic work and for anyone who appreciates intimate, rootsy songwriting.

Want me to compare this to another Neil Young album like Harvest or Old Ways? I can break down the stylistic contrasts, vinyl sound quality differences, or themes across records.